Packet J: Tossup 5

This thinker formalized a statement of equinumerosity that George Boolos later identified as Hume’s principle. (10[3])This thinker (-5[1])wrote two (10[1])essays criticizing David Hilbert’s lecture on geometry for relying on the demonstration of consistency. This thinker introduced the turnstile symbol to logic in a book that criticizes Kant’s claim that 2 + 3 = 5 (-5[1])was unprovable. (-5[1])Michael Dummett attributes the beginning (10[1])of the linguistic (-5[1])turn (10[1])to (-5[1])this (-5[1])thinker’s (-5[2])use (-5[1])of (-5[1])the (10[1])context principle (10[1]-5[1])while discussing (10[1]-5[1])the origin of numbers. (10[2])This thinker’s (-5[1])Basic Law V (10[5])(“five”) was shown to be (10[2])flawed (10[4])when considering sets through Russell’s paradox. (-5[1])A (10[1])puzzle at the start of a paper (10[1])by this thinker notes “Hesperus (10[1])is Hesperus. (10[1])Hesperus is Phosphorus.” (10[4])For 10 points, name this German (10[1])philosopher (-5[2])who wrote The Foundations (-5[1])of Arithmetic (10[1]-5[1])and On (10[1])Sense and Reference. (10[2]-5[1])■END■ (10[14]0[42])

ANSWER: Gottlob Frege
<Indiana A, Philosophy> | Packet J - Southampton A, Indiana A, Illinois B, Edinburgh A
= Average correct buzzpoint

Back to tossups

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzzpointValue
Asha BasuMcGill AWaterloo B1410
John MarvinChicago AChicago E1410
Eveline OngOxford AImperial C1410
Zaid AsifNYU CVassar16-5
Anuttam RamjiBerkeley BBerkeley A1810
Walter CarsonNC State BWake Forest53-5
Ian TheysmeyerQueen'sMcMaster A55-5
Jack LewisBruinWashU A6010
Moses KitakuleColumbia AJohns Hopkins A63-5
Mitch McCullarPenn StateRIT6410
Matthew SumanenGeorgia Tech CGeorgia Tech B65-5
Gus VanskikeMaryland CRutgers A66-5
Kevin YeSimon FraserToronto C67-5
Matt SheldonOxford BDurham67-5
Kerry XuUCSD BUCSD A68-5
Ryan RosenbergNYU AMaryland A69-5
Alex JiangBrownDartmouth B7010
Karthik JayaramUCLA AUC Irvine72-5
Matthew WangUBC AWaterloo A7210
Artem BorisovBristolEdinburgh B74-5
Jerry VinokurovJohn JayJohns Hopkins B7410
Michał GerasimiukStanford AStanford B7810
Ben HellmanSwarthmoreGeorgetown7810
Faraz ForoughiNC State ALiberty B80-5
Akshar GoyalIllinois AChicago B8310
Yrwin BatanMITYale8310
Joel MilesMinnesota AGeorgia Tech A8310
Albert NyangLSECambridge C8310
Oscar O'FlanaganImperial AUCL8310
Kevin ZhengMichigan AOhio State B8710
Jisoo YooTexas ATexas B8710
Nathaniel HullBerkeley CBerkeley D8810
Ariel FaederPittsburghCWRU B8810
Noah ChinVirginia Tech ANorth Carolina C8810
Kevin LiuMaryland BCatholic8810
Mats MillerChicago DNorthwestern D94-5
Chris YooWilliam and MaryVCU9510
Dmitri Anh-Minh TranUC Santa BarbaraUCSD C10210
Joseph ChambersVirginiaJames Madison A10710
Amir DolanskyToronto EGuelph10910
Emmanuel AlayandeFlorida BCentral Florida C11210
Chauncey LoColumbia CRutgers B11210
Omkar MaratheColumbia BNYU B11210
Robert ChenRochesterCornell C11210
Evan GniadekPurdue BChicago C11810
Stefan Stealey-EuchnerArizona StateUCLA B119-5
Owen RiviereWestern BWestern A119-5
Christopher BradleySouthern Connecticut StateHarvard A123-5
Sriram SusarlaUBC BCarleton University12510
Chris DechBrandeis ADartmouth A125-5
Arvin BoraghiCambridge BCity St. George's12710
Zachary BornsteinVirginia Tech BSouth Carolina A13010
Stephen WalshNorthwestern BIndiana B130-5
Sinecio MoralesJohns Hopkins AColumbia A13010
Jaskaran SinghUCLA BArizona State13110
Scott SibleyUC IrvineUCLA A1310
Nolan DannelsUCSD AUCSD B13110
Milan FernandezBrockMcGill B1310
Luke SloanMcGill BBrock1310
Seth AllenMcMaster AQueen's13110
Jesse ChusingOttawaToronto B13110
Yihong ChenToronto CSimon Fraser13110
Ishan JoshiToronto MetropolitanToronto D1310
Yusuf BaigMcMaster BToronto F1310
Saju RamrajToronto FMcMaster B1310
Sonia ZhangWestern AWestern B1310
Jay MisukWestern CToronto G1310
Khanh NguyenFlorida CCentral Florida B1310
AnnaMaria DonnellyCentral Florida BFlorida C1310
June MillerFlorida ACentral Florida A1310
Aryan DesarapuMichigan BMichigan State1310
Maddie BaldwinMichigan StateMichigan B1310
Thomas JenkinsMichigan CCWRU A1310
Andrew AmygdalosCWRU AMichigan C1310
Roxanne TangOhio State AOhio State C13110
Owen BanksDukeNorth Carolina A1310
Joseph ColeNorth Carolina ADuke1310
Kabir ZamanSouth Carolina BJames Madison B1310
Laila PetersonJames Madison BSouth Carolina B1310
James WatsonWake ForestNC State B1310
Ethan MaIllinois CIndiana C1310
Emily JustakIndiana CIllinois C1310
Jacob FinleyNotre Dame ANorthwestern C13110
Faith MagieraNorthwestern DChicago D1310
Nolan JonesPurdue ANotre Dame B1310
John AugustynNotre Dame BPurdue A1310
Elliott GomesDartmouth ABrandeis A1310
Max NealHarvard BBrandeis B13110
Joy AnHarvard ASouthern Connecticut State13110
Isaac StudleyCarleton CollegeMissouri B13110
Carson KesslerWashington BClaremont1310
Annika LarsonClaremontWashington B1310
Dwight SolanoTexas A&M AMurray State A1310
Kanyon BeckMurray State ATexas A&M A1310
Arhith DharanendraGeorgia Tech BGeorgia Tech C13110
Britton WebsterAlabama ALouisville B1310
Joseph StromLouisville BAlabama A1310
Sawyer SmithMississipi StateAlabama B1310
Davin SivertsonAlabama BMississipi State1310
Parker McCoigTennessee AGeorgia Tech D13110
Danny TranTennessee BSewanee1310
Camden WalkerWashU BKentucky1310
Olivia KiserKentuckyWashU B1310
Daniel BloomEdinburgh BBristol13110
Mattias EhatammMaryland ANYU A13110
Aiden DartleyRutgers AMaryland C1310
Eli O'Sick JohnsonBinghamton BBinghamton A1310
Peter SmithBinghamton ABinghamton B1310
Julian BushlowCornell ACornell B1310
Brian HoffCornell BCornell A1310

Summary

TournamentEditionMatchHeardConv. %Neg %Avg. Buzz
California (North)Main Site3100%0%61.33
California (South)Main Site475%75%121.33
CanadaMain Site1258%25%101.86
FloridaMain Site333%0%112.00
Great LakesMain Site560%0%102.00
Lower Mid-AtlanticMain Site944%22%105.00
MidwestMain Site850%25%86.50
NortheastMain Site580%40%103.75
OverflowMain Site367%0%107.00
South CentralMain Site250%0%87.00
SoutheastMain Site838%13%107.33
UKMain Site683%33%87.60
Upper Mid-AtlanticMain Site978%44%103.57
Upstate NYMain Site450%0%88.00