Round 1: Tossup 14

To address a problem often named for this kind of object, James Ross argues that it fails to consider a possible “state of affairs,” while Alvin Plantinga considers a being called “McEar” who can only scratch his ear. A passage involving one of these objects in a biography by James Boswell names a logical fallacy of claiming an argument is absurd without further reasoning. Thomas Aquinas used logical impossibility for a solution to a paradox named for these objects that concerned God’s omnipotence. A work of existentialism claims that pauses between a man’s use of one of these objects makes him “superior to his fate” and that, during his pauses, we must “imagine him happy.” (10[1])For 10 points, (10[1])an Albert Camus work described the absurdity of Sisyphus pushing what kind of object up a mountain? ■END■

ANSWER: stone [or boulder or rock; accept appeal to the stone; accept the Paradox of the Stone]
<EC, Philosophy> | Packet A - Brown A, Wisconsin A, Purdue, Maryland B
= Average correct buzzpoint

Back to tossups

Buzzes

PlayerTeamOpponentBuzzpointValue
Kanyon BeckMurray State ATexas B11410
Jisoo YooTexas ATexas A&M A11710

Summary

TournamentEditionMatchHeardConv. %Neg %Avg. Buzz
California (North)Main Site3100%0%59.00
California (South)Main Site4100%0%85.50
CanadaMain Site12100%25%108.17
FloridaMain Site367%33%120.00
Great LakesMain Site5100%20%94.80
Lower Mid-AtlanticMain Site9100%0%108.78
MidwestMain Site8100%13%90.75
OverflowMain Site4100%25%97.00
South CentralMain Site2100%0%115.50
SoutheastMain Site7100%0%107.14
UKMain Site12100%8%95.33
Upper Mid-AtlanticMain Site8100%0%93.88
Upstate NYMain Site4100%25%113.75